In an earlier post I laid out why it mathematically makes sense all securities, equities and bonds alike, decline when interest rates rise. Essentially, the cumulative value of future cash flows become less valuable in the present because the risk-free alternative has become more attractive. Instead of earning 0% in completely safe bank accounts, you can now earn over 3%. That makes folks less interested in taking a particular risk for 5-6% returns, and would perhaps demand 9-10% returns for equivalent risk.
At first blush, a 5% difference seems modest. But consider how it affects security prices. If we invest $100 in a security that will earn us $5, that’s a 5% return. But if we want to sell that security right now, when investors demand a 10% return, we’d only be able to sell it for $50. Obviously I’m simplifying a lot1, but at the core, that’s how interest rates can nosedive the value of a security from $100 to $50.
Nevertheless, it is largely irrelevant to us, the patient investor.
Because if we ignore the price movements and don’t sell, and the security delivers its cash flows year in and year out, the value still accretes. The cash piles up irrespective of day-to-day interest rate movements and we continue to earn our return! If we put our $100 investment in a lockbox and don’t bother stressing about its present value on a regular basis, the only thing we care about is the cash it’s generating for us: the $5 annual return. And whether it can potentially grow to $6, $8, $12, and beyond in the years ahead.
We cannot control interest rates, nor can we control the perception of market participants. What we can control is the accuracy of our analysis and the decision to buy or sell based on what the market is offering2.
Our holy grail is an environment where interest rates are at or near a peak (thereby weighing on prices but without the prospect of further declines) and other investors are indiscriminately fearful (thereby demanding a higher rate of return, which further weighs on prices). When we invest in this environment, we get to own not just the intrinsic value of capable corporations growing their per-share values over time, but also the possibility of a lower interest rate future and improving investor sentiment that could pull forward even greater returns.
This idea, in essence, is why we value investors shouldn’t sweat the macro. Interest rates and elections and geopolitics and the animal spirits of markets will always be unpredictable. Good businesses purchased at reasonable prices will endure. Accordingly, I increasingly think of us as collectors: We collect enduring assets that benefit from time.
_____________________________________
1 Don’t @ me, bond people.
2 Simple, but not easy. I’m by no means saying this business is a walk in the park and everyone else is stupid.
